Overview

Is it worth going back to work once you pay for daycare? This compares the second earner's take-home pay with the cost of childcare and commuting, plus the 401(k) match that would be lost.

Enter the gross salary, an effective tax rate, monthly daycare, daily commute cost and the yearly employer match.

Worked examples

InputsResult
Lower Earner Gross Annual Salary ($)62,000Effective Tax Rate (%)24Monthly Daycare Cost ($)1,650Daily Commute Cost ($)18Annual 401k Match Lost If Quitting ($)3,500Working nets $1,946.67 per month after daycare and commuteIf you quit, annual 401(k) match loss: $3,500.00Total annual opportunity delta: $26,860.00
Show 2 more examples
Lower Earner Gross Annual Salary ($)45,000Effective Tax Rate (%)18Monthly Daycare Cost ($)2,100Daily Commute Cost ($)12Annual 401k Match Lost If Quitting ($)1,500Working nets $755.00 per month after daycare and commuteIf you quit, annual 401(k) match loss: $1,500.00Total annual opportunity delta: $10,560.00
Lower Earner Gross Annual Salary ($)90,000Effective Tax Rate (%)28Monthly Daycare Cost ($)1,400Daily Commute Cost ($)10Annual 401k Match Lost If Quitting ($)5,000Working nets $3,816.67 per month after daycare and commuteIf you quit, annual 401(k) match loss: $5,000.00Total annual opportunity delta: $50,800.00

Stay at Home vs Daycare Reality Check by effective tax rate

With the calculator's starting values, the result is Working nets $1,946.67 per month after daycare and commute. The table shows how it changes with the effective tax rate.

Effective Tax Rate (%)Stay at Home vs Daycare Reality Check
15%Working nets $2,411.67 per month after daycare and commute
20%Working nets $2,153.33 per month after daycare and commute
24%starting valueWorking nets $1,946.67 per month after daycare and commute
25%Working nets $1,895.00 per month after daycare and commute
30%Working nets $1,636.67 per month after daycare and commute
35%Working nets $1,378.33 per month after daycare and commute

Other inputs: Lower Earner Gross Annual Salary: $62,000 · Monthly Daycare Cost: $1,650 · Daily Commute Cost: $18 · Annual 401k Match Lost If Quitting: $3,500. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.

How it works

After-tax income is the salary minus your effective tax rate. Daycare is the monthly cost times 12, and commuting is the daily cost times 220 working days. What's left is the net gain from working. Adding the 401(k) match gives the full yearly difference between working and staying home.

The formula

Net from working = salary × (1 − tax) − daycare × 12 − commute × 220
effective tax rateTotal tax as a share of gross pay, not your top bracket
220Assumed working days per year

Practical tips

  • $62,000 at 24% tax, $1,650 a month daycare and $18 a day commuting nets about $1,947 a month.
  • Daycare usually drops once children start school, so look at the next five years, not just this one.
  • Career gaps can reduce future earnings, which this doesn't include.

Frequently asked questions

Should I use gross or take-home pay?

Enter the gross salary with your effective tax rate, and the calculator works out the take-home part.

What else should I consider?

Health insurance, Social Security credits, career progress and what each option is like for your family.

Does this include childcare tax credits?

No. Credits or a dependent care FSA can lower the real daycare cost.