Overview
Some renovations pay back through lower bills or extra rent, and some through a higher sale price. This combines both over the time until you sell, with a discount for the chance things don't go as planned.
Enter the cost, the monthly value gain, the expected resale uplift, years until sale, and a risk discount. 20% is a sensible cautious default.
Worked examples
| Inputs | Result |
|---|---|
| Renovation Cost ($)38,000Estimated Monthly Value Gain ($)260Expected Resale Uplift ($)18,000Years until Sale5Risk Discount (%)20 | Risk-adjusted payback: 182.69 monthsHorizon benefit (5y): $26,880.00Net outcome: -$11,120.00Horizon ROI: -29.26% |
Show 2 more examples
| Renovation Cost ($)15,000Estimated Monthly Value Gain ($)120Expected Resale Uplift ($)10,000Years until Sale10Risk Discount (%)20 | Risk-adjusted payback: 156.25 monthsHorizon benefit (10y): $19,520.00Net outcome: $4,520.00Horizon ROI: 30.13% |
| Renovation Cost ($)60,000Estimated Monthly Value Gain ($)0Expected Resale Uplift ($)45,000Years until Sale2Risk Discount (%)30 | Risk-adjusted payback: No monthly payback (monthly gain is 0)Horizon benefit (2y): $31,500.00Net outcome: -$28,500.00Horizon ROI: -47.5% |
Risk-adjusted payback by estimated monthly value gain
With the calculator's starting values, the risk-adjusted payback is 182.69 months. The table shows how it changes with the estimated monthly value gain.
| Estimated Monthly Value Gain ($) | Risk-adjusted payback (months) |
|---|---|
| $150 | 316.67 months |
| $200 | 237.5 months |
| $250 | 190 months |
| $260starting value | 182.69 months |
| $300 | 158.33 months |
| $350 | 135.71 months |
Other inputs: Renovation Cost: $38,000 · Expected Resale Uplift: $18,000 · Years until Sale: 5 · Risk Discount: 20%. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.
How it works
The monthly gain and resale uplift are both reduced by the risk discount. Payback is the cost divided by the adjusted monthly gain. The horizon benefit adds the monthly gains until sale and the resale uplift. Net outcome and ROI compare that benefit with the cost. It doesn't discount future money or include financing costs.
The formula
| risk discount | How much to trim estimates for uncertainty |
Practical tips
- A $38,000 project gaining $260 a month and $18,000 at resale over 5 years nets about −$11,120 after a 20% risk discount.
- Few renovations recover their full cost at resale. Kitchens and bathrooms often recover only part.
- Count energy savings, rental income or avoided repairs as the monthly gain.
Frequently asked questions
Where can I find resale uplift figures?
Local agents and cost-versus-value surveys give typical recovery rates for common projects.
Should I renovate if the ROI is negative?
Possibly, if you'll enjoy it. Just treat the shortfall as a cost of living there.
Does this include financing?
No. If you borrow, add the interest to the cost.