Overview

A higher salary isn't always the better offer once costs and benefits differ. This compares two offers after tax and the extra costs and benefits of the counteroffer.

Enter both salaries, your effective tax rate, and any yearly extra costs and extra benefits in the counteroffer role.

Worked examples

InputsResult
Base Offer Salary ($)120,000Counter Offer Salary ($)128,000Effective Tax Rate (%)27Annual Extra Costs in Counter Role ($)4,000Annual Extra Benefits in Counter Role ($)6,000Base net annual: $87,600.00Counter net annual: $95,440.00Delta: $7,840.00 /yr ($653.33 /mo)Counter offer is financially stronger
Show 2 more examples
Base Offer Salary ($)80,000Counter Offer Salary ($)85,000Effective Tax Rate (%)22Annual Extra Costs in Counter Role ($)3,000Annual Extra Benefits in Counter Role ($)0Base net annual: $62,400.00Counter net annual: $63,300.00Delta: $900.00 /yr ($75.00 /mo)Counter offer is financially stronger
Base Offer Salary ($)150,000Counter Offer Salary ($)140,000Effective Tax Rate (%)30Annual Extra Costs in Counter Role ($)0Annual Extra Benefits in Counter Role ($)12,000Base net annual: $105,000.00Counter net annual: $110,000.00Delta: $5,000.00 /yr ($416.67 /mo)Counter offer is financially stronger

Base net annual by effective tax rate

With the calculator's starting values, the base net annual is $87,600.00. The table shows how it changes with the effective tax rate.

Effective Tax Rate (%)Base net annual
15%$102,000.00
20%$96,000.00
25%$90,000.00
27%starting value$87,600.00
30%$84,000.00
35%$78,000.00
40%$72,000.00

Other inputs: Base Offer Salary: $120,000 · Counter Offer Salary: $128,000 · Annual Extra Costs in Counter Role: $4,000 · Annual Extra Benefits in Counter Role: $6,000. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.

How it works

Both salaries are reduced by the same effective tax rate. The counteroffer then has its extra costs subtracted and its extra benefits added, treated as already after tax. The difference is shown per year and per month.

The formula

Gain = counter × (1 − tax) − costs + benefits − base × (1 − tax)
effective tax rateTotal tax as a share of gross pay

Practical tips

  • $120,000 against $128,000 at 27% tax, with $4,000 of extra costs and $6,000 of benefits, favors the counter by $7,840 a year.
  • Include commuting, parking and childcare changes in extra costs.
  • Put a value on extra paid leave, a bigger retirement match or better health cover as extra benefits.

Frequently asked questions

Should I accept a counteroffer from my current employer?

Think about why you started looking. Pay rarely fixes other problems.

Is the same tax rate fair?

It's a simplification. A higher salary may be taxed at a slightly higher marginal rate.

What benefits should I count?

Anything with a clear money value, such as retirement match, bonuses and insurance savings.