Overview
Should the team build a new feature or fix technical debt first? This compares how quickly each pays back its cost.
Enter each option's cost and the monthly benefit you expect, such as new revenue for the feature or saved engineering time for the debt fix.
Worked examples
| Inputs | Result |
|---|---|
| Feature Cost ($)28,000Feature Monthly Benefit ($)4,200Debt Fix Cost ($)18,000Debt Monthly Benefit ($)2,600 | Feature payback: 6.67 moDebt payback: 6.92 moFeature path pays back faster |
Show 2 more examples
| Feature Cost ($)50,000Feature Monthly Benefit ($)5,000Debt Fix Cost ($)20,000Debt Monthly Benefit ($)3,000 | Feature payback: 10 moDebt payback: 6.67 moDebt payoff pays back faster |
| Feature Cost ($)10,000Feature Monthly Benefit ($)500Debt Fix Cost ($)40,000Debt Monthly Benefit ($)4,000 | Feature payback: 20 moDebt payback: 10 moDebt payoff pays back faster |
Feature payback by feature monthly benefit
With the calculator's starting values, the feature payback is 6.67 mo. The table shows how it changes with the feature monthly benefit.
| Feature Monthly Benefit ($) | Feature payback (mo) |
|---|---|
| $3,000 | 9.33 mo |
| $4,000 | 7 mo |
| $4,200starting value | 6.67 mo |
| $5,000 | 5.6 mo |
| $6,000 | 4.67 mo |
Other inputs: Feature Cost: $28,000 · Debt Fix Cost: $18,000 · Debt Monthly Benefit: $2,600. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.
How it works
Payback is cost ÷ monthly benefit, and the shorter one wins. It ignores risk, timing and strategic value, so use it alongside judgment. Debt fixes often have benefits that compound, such as faster future work.
The formula
Practical tips
- A $28,000 feature earning $4,200 a month pays back in 6.67 months, against 6.92 for an $18,000 debt fix saving $2,600.
- Value saved engineering hours at your loaded hourly cost.
- Close results mean other factors, such as risk or morale, should decide.
Frequently asked questions
How do I estimate a debt fix's benefit?
Hours saved each month on bugs, deploys or slow builds, times the hourly cost.
Should I always pick the faster payback?
Not necessarily. Strategic or risk-reducing work can be worth more.
What about benefits that grow over time?
This uses a constant monthly benefit, so growing benefits pay back sooner.