Overview
Doing a job yourself saves on labor, but it costs your time and carries a risk of mistakes. This compares the true cost of DIY with a contractor's quote.
Enter the quote, your materials and tool rental, what an hour of your time is worth, the hours you expect it to take, and a mistake allowance. 15 to 25% is typical for a first project.
Worked examples
| Inputs | Result |
|---|---|
| Contractor Quote ($)14,500DIY Materials Plus Tool Rental Cost ($)7,200Your Hourly Time Value ($)45Estimated DIY Hours80Mistake Multiplier (%)20 | DIY true cost: $12,240.00Cash-only savings vs quote: $5,860.00Effective hourly pay for DIY time: $73.25/hrTrue savings vs hiring: $2,260.00DIY is financially ahead on total-cost basis. |
Show 2 more examples
| Contractor Quote ($)3,000DIY Materials Plus Tool Rental Cost ($)900Your Hourly Time Value ($)30Estimated DIY Hours20Mistake Multiplier (%)15 | DIY true cost: $1,635.00Cash-only savings vs quote: $1,965.00Effective hourly pay for DIY time: $98.25/hrTrue savings vs hiring: $1,365.00DIY is financially ahead on total-cost basis. |
| Contractor Quote ($)8,000DIY Materials Plus Tool Rental Cost ($)3,500Your Hourly Time Value ($)75Estimated DIY Hours60Mistake Multiplier (%)25 | DIY true cost: $8,875.00Cash-only savings vs quote: $3,625.00Effective hourly pay for DIY time: $60.42/hrTrue savings vs hiring: -$875.00Hiring a pro is financially better on total-cost basis. |
DIY true cost by DIY materials plus tool rental cost
With the calculator's starting values, the DIY true cost is $12,240.00. The table shows how it changes with the DIY materials plus tool rental cost.
| DIY Materials Plus Tool Rental Cost ($) | DIY true cost |
|---|---|
| $4,000 | $8,400.00 |
| $5,000 | $9,600.00 |
| $6,000 | $10,800.00 |
| $7,000 | $12,000.00 |
| $7,200starting value | $12,240.00 |
| $8,000 | $13,200.00 |
| $9,000 | $14,400.00 |
| $10,000 | $15,600.00 |
Other inputs: Contractor Quote: $14,500 · Your Hourly Time Value: $45 · Estimated DIY Hours: 80 · Mistake Multiplier: 20%. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.
How it works
Materials are increased by the mistake allowance to cover wasted materials and do-overs. Your hours are valued at your hourly rate. The two together are your true DIY cost, which is compared with the quote. The effective hourly pay is the cash saved divided by your hours.
The formula
Practical tips
- Against a $14,500 quote, $7,200 of materials with 20% for mistakes plus 80 hours at $45 costs $12,240, a true saving of $2,260.
- First-timers often take 1.5 to 2 times as long as a professional, so be honest about the hours.
- Some jobs, such as electrical or gas work, need licensed professionals or permits.
Frequently asked questions
What hourly value should I use?
What you could earn instead, or what your free time is worth to you.
What does the mistake allowance cover?
Wasted materials, extra tools and redoing parts of the job.
What about warranties?
Contractors usually guarantee their work. DIY has no such cover, which is worth weighing too.