Overview

Is a degree worth the cost? This compares 30 years of earnings after college, minus 10 years of loan payments, with working straight away and investing the same money in an index fund.

Enter the total cost or debt, the loan rate, the expected starting salaries with and without the degree, and an index fund return.

Worked examples

InputsResult
Total Tuition and Debt ($)100,000Student Loan Interest Rate (%)6.2Expected Starting Salary with Degree ($)62,000Expected Starting Salary without Degree ($)38,000Expected Index Return (%)7Loan payment: $1,120.28/moCollege-path vs work+invest delta at 30 years: $385,714.53Break-even age: age 31
Show 2 more examples
Total Tuition and Debt ($)40,000Student Loan Interest Rate (%)5.5Expected Starting Salary with Degree ($)55,000Expected Starting Salary without Degree ($)38,000Expected Index Return (%)7Loan payment: $434.11/moCollege-path vs work+invest delta at 30 years: $591,762.33Break-even age: age 23
Total Tuition and Debt ($)200,000Student Loan Interest Rate (%)7Expected Starting Salary with Degree ($)70,000Expected Starting Salary without Degree ($)40,000Expected Index Return (%)6Loan payment: $2,322.17/moCollege-path vs work+invest delta at 30 years: $146,812.39Break-even age: age 41

Loan payment by student loan interest rate

With the calculator's starting values, the loan payment is $1,120.28/mo. The table shows how it changes with the student loan interest rate.

Student Loan Interest Rate (%)Loan payment
4%$1,012.45/mo
5%$1,060.66/mo
6%$1,110.21/mo
6.2%starting value$1,120.28/mo
7%$1,161.08/mo
8%$1,213.28/mo
9%$1,266.76/mo

Other inputs: Total Tuition and Debt: $100,000 · Expected Starting Salary with Degree: $62,000 · Expected Starting Salary without Degree: $38,000 · Expected Index Return: 7%. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.

How it works

Loan payments are for a 10-year loan. Salaries with a degree grow 3% a year and without one grow 2.5% a year, both fixed assumptions. The other path invests the degree's cost up front and lets it grow at your chosen return. Wealth here means total earnings minus loan costs, before tax and living costs, and the years spent studying are not deducted.

The formula

Loan payment uses the standard formula over 120 months
3% and 2.5%Assumed yearly salary growth with and without a degree

Practical tips

  • $100,000 at 6.2% costs about $1,120 a month over 10 years.
  • Earnings vary far more by field, job and location than by degree alone, so use realistic salaries for the specific major.
  • Run it with a lower salary gap to see how sensitive the result is.

Frequently asked questions

Does this include lost earnings while studying?

No, it starts both paths at the same time. Four years out of work would narrow the gap.

Why compare with an index fund?

It's a simple way to show what the same money might earn if it were invested instead.

Are taxes included?

No. Higher earnings pay more tax, which would reduce the college path's advantage somewhat.