Overview

A traditional IRA gives the tax break now, and a Roth gives it in retirement. The better choice mostly depends on whether your tax rate will be higher now or later.

Enter the same pre-tax amount for both, and your two tax rates. The Roth side pays tax up front, so less goes in.

Worked examples

InputsResult
Yearly pre-tax amount to invest ($)7,000Years until retirement30Expected annual return (%)7Tax rate now (%)22Tax rate in retirement (%)15Traditional leaves $46,286 moreRoth after tax: $515,756Traditional after tax: $562,042
Show 2 more examples
Yearly pre-tax amount to invest ($)7,000Years until retirement30Expected annual return (%)7Tax rate now (%)15Tax rate in retirement (%)22Roth leaves $46,286 moreRoth after tax: $562,042Traditional after tax: $515,756
Yearly pre-tax amount to invest ($)7,000Years until retirement30Expected annual return (%)7Tax rate now (%)20Tax rate in retirement (%)20They come out the sameRoth after tax: $528,980Traditional after tax: $528,980

Result (more) by tax rate now

With the calculator's starting values, the result is Traditional leaves $46,286 more. The table shows how it changes with the tax rate now.

Tax rate now (%)Result (more)
20%Traditional leaves $33,061 more
22%starting valueTraditional leaves $46,286 more
25%Traditional leaves $66,123 more
30%Traditional leaves $99,184 more

Other inputs: Yearly pre-tax amount to invest: $7,000 · Years until retirement: 30 · Expected annual return: 7% · Tax rate in retirement: 15%. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.

How it works

The Roth invests the amount after today’s tax, and withdrawals are tax free. The traditional account invests the full amount, and withdrawals are taxed at your retirement rate. When the two rates are equal, the results match exactly. A lower rate in retirement favors traditional, and a higher one favors Roth.

The formula

Roth = C(1 − t_now) × G; Traditional = C × G × (1 − t_later)
CYearly pre-tax amount
GGrowth factor for all contributions
tTax rates now and later

Practical tips

  • At $7,000 a year for 30 years at 7%, going from a 22% to a 15% rate leaves traditional about $46,000 ahead.
  • Tax rates in retirement are a guess, so splitting between both can hedge your bets.
  • This ignores income limits, deductibility rules and required distributions.

Frequently asked questions

Why do the two tie at equal tax rates?

Multiplying by growth and by one minus the tax rate gives the same result in either order.

Do Roth IRAs have required distributions?

Not for the original owner. Traditional IRAs do, starting at age 73 under current rules.