Overview
Should you rent and invest the difference, or buy? This simulates both paths over 20 years with today's rent, rent growth, home price, mortgage rate and an investment return.
Enter your current rent, the yearly rent increase, the home price, the mortgage rate and the expected investment return. It makes several fixed assumptions, listed below.
Worked examples
| Inputs | Result |
|---|---|
| Current Monthly Rent ($)2,400Annual Rent Increase (%)4Home Purchase Price ($)520,000Mortgage Rate (%)6.9Expected Stock Return (%)7 | 10-year rent path advantage: $171,916.33 (positive means rent+invest leads)Renting+investing stays ahead within a 20-year horizonMonthly mortgage (principal+interest): $2,739.78 |
Show 2 more examples
| Current Monthly Rent ($)1,800Annual Rent Increase (%)3Home Purchase Price ($)350,000Mortgage Rate (%)6Expected Stock Return (%)7 | 10-year rent path advantage: $75,599.81 (positive means rent+invest leads)Renting+investing stays ahead within a 20-year horizonMonthly mortgage (principal+interest): $1,678.74 |
| Current Monthly Rent ($)3,500Annual Rent Increase (%)5Home Purchase Price ($)700,000Mortgage Rate (%)5.5Expected Stock Return (%)6 | 10-year rent path advantage: $65,730.95 (positive means rent+invest leads)Buying overtakes renting after about 15 yearsMonthly mortgage (principal+interest): $3,179.62 |
10-year rent path advantage by mortgage rate
With the calculator's starting values, the 10-year rent path advantage is $171,916.33. The table shows how it changes with the mortgage rate.
| Mortgage Rate (%) | 10-year rent path advantage |
|---|---|
| 4% | $53,074.84 |
| 5% | $93,372.20 |
| 6% | $134,436.09 |
| 6.9%starting value | $171,916.33 |
| 7% | $176,106.38 |
| 8% | $218,237.90 |
| 9% | $260,703.20 |
| 10% | $303,393.74 |
Other inputs: Current Monthly Rent: $2,400 · Annual Rent Increase: 4% · Home Purchase Price: $520,000 · Expected Stock Return: 7%. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.
How it works
Buying assumes 20% down, 3% closing costs, a 30-year mortgage, property tax at 1.2% a year, maintenance at 1% and insurance at 0.35% of the price. Unrecoverable costs, such as interest, tax, maintenance and insurance, are compared with rent. The renter is assumed to invest the down payment and closing costs at your return. Home price growth isn't modeled separately, so treat this as one view of the decision.
Practical tips
- At the defaults, renting and investing stays ahead over 20 years, mainly because of the 6.9% mortgage rate.
- Lower mortgage rates or faster rent growth tip the result toward buying.
- Run it with a lower investment return. Returns aren't guaranteed.
Frequently asked questions
Why compare unrecoverable costs?
Principal payments build equity, so they aren't lost the way rent and interest are.
Does it include home price growth?
Not directly. Rising home values would favor buying.
Is 20% down required?
No, but it's assumed here. Less down usually adds PMI.