Overview

Choosing between a high-deductible health plan (HDHP) with an HSA and a PPO? This compares their yearly cost in a low, medium and high medical-spending year.

Enter both monthly premiums, both deductibles and the employer's HSA contribution. The model uses several fixed assumptions, so check your plan's real out-of-pocket maximum and coinsurance.

Worked examples

InputsResult
HDHP Monthly Premium ($)210PPO Monthly Premium ($)320HDHP Deductible ($)3,400PPO Deductible ($)1,200Employer HSA Contribution ($)1,200Low-use year: HDHP saves $2,808.00Catastrophic year: PPO saves $2,272.00Mid-use difference: $568.00 (PPO - HDHP)HDHP recommended
Show 2 more examples
HDHP Monthly Premium ($)150PPO Monthly Premium ($)300HDHP Deductible ($)4,000PPO Deductible ($)1,500Employer HSA Contribution ($)500Low-use year: HDHP saves $2,420.00Catastrophic year: PPO saves $2,780.00Mid-use difference: -$30.00 (PPO - HDHP)PPO recommended
HDHP Monthly Premium ($)250PPO Monthly Premium ($)280HDHP Deductible ($)2,800PPO Deductible ($)1,000Employer HSA Contribution ($)1,000Low-use year: HDHP saves $1,420.00Catastrophic year: PPO saves $2,560.00Mid-use difference: -$340.00 (PPO - HDHP)PPO recommended

Low-use year by PPO monthly premium

With the calculator's starting values, the low-use year is HDHP saves $2,808.00. The table shows how it changes with the PPO monthly premium.

PPO Monthly Premium ($)Low-use year
$200HDHP saves $1,368.00
$250HDHP saves $1,968.00
$300HDHP saves $2,568.00
$320starting valueHDHP saves $2,808.00
$350HDHP saves $3,168.00
$400HDHP saves $3,768.00
$450HDHP saves $4,368.00

Other inputs: HDHP Monthly Premium: $210 · HDHP Deductible: $3,400 · PPO Deductible: $1,200 · Employer HSA Contribution: $1,200. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.

How it works

Spending scenarios are $1,200, $6,000 and $25,000 of medical bills. Out-of-pocket costs are the deductible, then 20% coinsurance for the HDHP or 10% for the PPO. Out-of-pocket maximums are assumed to be 2.2× and 2× the deductibles. The HDHP's cost is reduced by the employer HSA contribution and a 24% tax saving on it. Premiums are added to give the total.

Practical tips

  • At the defaults, the HDHP saves about $2,800 in a low-use year, while the PPO saves about $2,270 in a very expensive one.
  • Replace the assumed maximums with your plan's real ones, which are on the summary of benefits.
  • Your own HSA contributions also get a tax saving, which makes the HDHP more attractive.

Frequently asked questions

What is an HSA?

A tax-advantaged savings account paired with an HDHP. Unused money rolls over and can be invested.

When is a PPO better?

Usually when you expect high, predictable medical costs, or need a wider network.

Are prescriptions included?

Include expected costs in your spending, since plans treat them differently.