Overview
Two loan offers can look alike but cost very different amounts once rate, term and fees are combined. A lower payment often comes from a longer term and more total interest.
Enter the same loan amount, then each offer’s rate, term and fees to see which is cheaper overall and which has the lower monthly payment.
Worked examples
| Inputs | Result |
|---|---|
| Loan amount ($)20,000Offer A: rate (% per year)6.5Offer A: term (years)5Offer A: fees ($)0Offer B: rate (% per year)5.9Offer B: term (years)7Offer B: fees ($)300 | Offer A: $391.32/month, total cost $23,479Offer B: $291.21/month, total cost $24,762Offer A is cheaper overall by $1,283Offer B has the lower monthly payment ($100.11 less) |
Show 2 more examples
| Loan amount ($)15,000Offer A: rate (% per year)7Offer A: term (years)4Offer A: fees ($)100Offer B: rate (% per year)6.4Offer B: term (years)5Offer B: fees ($)250 | Offer A: $359.19/month, total cost $17,341Offer B: $292.79/month, total cost $17,817Offer A is cheaper overall by $476Offer B has the lower monthly payment ($66.40 less) |
| Loan amount ($)35,000Offer A: rate (% per year)5.5Offer A: term (years)10Offer A: fees ($)0Offer B: rate (% per year)4.9Offer B: term (years)15Offer B: fees ($)500 | Offer A: $379.84/month, total cost $45,581Offer B: $274.96/month, total cost $49,992Offer A is cheaper overall by $4,411Offer B has the lower monthly payment ($104.88 less) |
How it works
Each offer’s payment comes from the amortization formula. The total cost is that payment times the number of months, plus any upfront fees.
The formula
| Payment | Monthly payment for the offer |
| n | Number of months in the term |
Practical tips
- For $20,000, 6.5% over 5 years ($391.32 a month) beats 5.9% over 7 years with a $300 fee, which costs $24,762 in total versus $23,479.
- A lower payment is not the same as a cheaper loan.
- If you plan to pay early, compare offers by rate and fees, not term.
Frequently asked questions
Which matters more, rate or term?
Both. A lower rate saves money, but stretching the term adds interest even at a lower rate.
Should fees be included?
Yes. Origination and other upfront fees add to the real cost, so include them.