Overview
Many US freelancers consider an S corporation to save self-employment tax. This gives a rough comparison of taxes as a sole proprietor and as an S corp, and the profit level where the switch starts to pay.
Enter gross 1099 income, business expenses, your state tax rate, the share of profit you'd pay yourself as salary, and yearly S corp running costs. This is a rough model, so confirm with a CPA before electing S corp status.
Worked examples
| Inputs | Result |
|---|---|
| Gross 1099 Income ($)210,000Business Expenses ($)48,000State Tax Rate (%)6.5Reasonable Salary Share (%)55Annual S Corp Admin Cost ($)1,800 | Schedule C est. tax: $69,059.87S-Corp est. tax+admin: $57,447.00Net annual benefit: $11,612.87Estimated break-even profit: $30,000.00 |
Show 2 more examples
| Gross 1099 Income ($)90,000Business Expenses ($)15,000State Tax Rate (%)5Reasonable Salary Share (%)60Annual S Corp Admin Cost ($)1,500 | Schedule C est. tax: $30,847.16S-Corp est. tax+admin: $27,015.00Net annual benefit: $3,832.16Estimated break-even profit: $30,000.00 |
| Gross 1099 Income ($)350,000Business Expenses ($)60,000State Tax Rate (%)9Reasonable Salary Share (%)45Annual S Corp Admin Cost ($)2,500 | Schedule C est. tax: $130,875.70S-Corp est. tax+admin: $102,477.50Net annual benefit: $28,398.20Estimated break-even profit: $30,000.00 |
Schedule C est. tax by gross 1099 income
With the calculator's starting values, the schedule c est. tax is $69,059.87. The table shows how it changes with the gross 1099 income.
| Gross 1099 Income ($) | Schedule C est. tax |
|---|---|
| $150,000 | $43,482.14 |
| $200,000 | $64,796.92 |
| $210,000starting value | $69,059.87 |
| $250,000 | $86,111.69 |
| $300,000 | $107,426.47 |
Other inputs: Business Expenses: $48,000 · State Tax Rate: 6.5% · Reasonable Salary Share: 55% · Annual S Corp Admin Cost: $1,800. Change them in the calculator above for your own numbers.
How it works
As a sole proprietor, self-employment tax is 15.3% of 92.35% of profit, plus income tax at a flat 22% federal rate plus your state rate. As an S corp, payroll tax is 15.3% of your salary only, and income tax uses the same rate, with distributions reduced by 20% to reflect the qualified business income deduction. It ignores the Social Security wage cap, the SE tax deduction and tax brackets.
The formula
| reasonable salary | What you'd pay yourself through payroll. The IRS expects it to be fair for your work |
Practical tips
- At the defaults, the estimated saving is about $11,600 a year.
- Too low a salary attracts IRS scrutiny. Many advisers start around market pay for your role.
- Payroll services, extra tax filings and state fees add up, so include them in admin cost.
Frequently asked questions
When does an S corp make sense?
Advisers often suggest considering it once profit is reliably above roughly $40,000 to $80,000, but it depends on your situation.
What is reasonable salary?
Pay similar to what you'd earn as an employee doing the same work.
Does this include the QBI deduction exactly?
No. It uses a simple 20% reduction on distributions. Real eligibility and limits vary.